Piece of Cake Bakery
Piece of Cake Cookie Shop
Piece of Cake Bakery Menu
Photo Gallery
What's New
Weddings
About Us
Frequently Asked Questions

Become a Fan

Menu

Cake

Our highly decorated cakes including but not limited to; shaped, semi-dimensional and tiered should be ordered and prepaid at least one week in advance. Especially during wedding season. Order early to insure we will be able to accommodate your order

*Please call for pricing on all decorated cakes  

 

Cupcakes

Cup Cake price includes: white butter cream frosting.  All cupcakes will have a classic swirl and sprinkles unless otherwise specified.

Chocolate, Cream Cheese or Custom Color Butter Cream Icing add $1.00 per six pack

Classic: Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry • Butter $4.50 six pack (Available any time)

Select: Chocolate Chip • Double Chocolate • Lemon • Spice • Funfetti $4.95 six pack (Must order 72 hours in advance, minimum order one six pack)

Cakes

Most of our highly decorated cakes use butter cream icing as the main frosting. Chocolate, Cream Cheese & Whipped Creme are available with limited decor

Classic Cake Flavors: Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry • Butter • Marble • Lemon • Funfetti
 
Select Cake Flavors: Banana • Chocolate Chip • Double Chocolate • Spice
 
Shaped Cakes are available in Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry • Butter • Marble • Banana • Spice • Lemon • Funfetti
 
3D & Semi-dimensional Cakes are available in: Chocolate Pound • Butter • Marble

mocha java

Specialty Cakes

Specialty cakes are both beautiful & delicious, however they do not come with extra decor
8″ Round – $21.95 (other sizes available call for pricing)
1/4 sheet – $27.95 1/3 sheet – $34.95 1/2 sheet – $46.95 full sheet – $59.95
Six pack Cupcakes- $6.95 (minimum order one dozen)
 
Pink Coconut - Grandma Gossard (our dad’s mom) used to make a delicious coconut cake that she would take to the PTA dances during World War II. To make it extra special she would dye the icing a light pink. Today we make grandma’s recipe and we think you will love it
 
Mocha Java- Coffee is an excellent accent to chocolate. Our mocha java cake combines both chocolate & coffee with a hint of cinnamon. The finishing touch our mocha frosting, a light chocolate frosting with a coffee kick
 
Peanut Butter Flip – Moist chocolate cake iced in decadent peanut butter cream frosting
 
Red Velvet – Beautiful & rich chocolate sour cream cake frosted with our made from scratch cream cheese icing. This cake is a favorite of Cate’s daughter Alyssa
 

Signature Cakes

Pineapple Upside Down Cake -This cake is only available as a sheet cake. Our delicious butter cake, made with pineapple juice then poured onto a layer of butter, brown sugar, pineapple & cherries. Then we bake until golden brown, flip out of the pan for a mouth watering pineapple upside down cake!  
 
Signature cakes are both beautiful & delicious, however they do not come with extra decor
 
Double Layer 8 inch round – $26.95 (other sizes available call for pricing)
1/4 sheet – $32.95 1/3 sheet – $43.95 1/2 sheet – $55.95 full sheet – $69.95
Six pack Cupcakes- $9.95 (minimum one dozen, *Indicates flavors available as cupcakes)
Banana Cream Cake – This is one of my favorite cakes. Our delicious buttery banana cake frosted in whipped creme with banana pudding on top and between the layers then sprinkled with crushed graham cracker crumbs
 
 
Boston Cream Pie- Our moist butter cake filled with vanilla mousse, covered in rich chocolate frosting & topped with ganache*
 
Butter Rum Cake-Our delicious butter cake soaked in our secret rum sauce, iced with whipped creme & topped with rich chocolate ganache*
 
Capuccino Cake-Mocha cake with whipped creme between the layers, covered in our wonderful
 
Carrot – The first time I had this cake we were staying with my Aunt Carol the summer I turned twelve. I couldn’t believe that a cake made with a vegetable could taste this darn good! Of course covering it with that delicious cream cheese frosting didn’t hurt. Our made from scratch cake, is full of shredded carrots & toasted pecans then iced with our cream cheese icing*
 
Chocolate Covered Cherry- This cake is a close cousin to the black forrest cake… Rich chocolate icing replaces the whipped creme icing for an exceptionally decadent dessert
 
Chocolate 4-Ever-This cake is truely a chocoholics favorite cake! It combines our chocolate cake with chocolate chips baked into it. Then we cover the cake with chocolate frosting and top it with       chocolate ganache. This cake defines what a decadent dessert should be*
 
Chocolate Moose Cake – Chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse, covered in whipped creme and topped with chocolate ganache. This cake is triple chocolatey, yet still light & delicious
 
Chocolate Rum Cake – This cake is our own version of rum cake. Ours is made with moist chocolate cake soaked in our sweet rum sauce, covered in whipped creme & topped with chocolate ganache. Real dark rum, gives this cake a distinctive flavor*
 
German Chocolate- Double layer chocolate cake torted and filled with gooey, made from scratch, German chocolate frosting. For a finishing touch this cake is iced with chocolate frosting then topped with more coconut, pecan frosting*
 
Italian Cream Cake – Rich buttermilk, coconut, pecan cake, iced with our cream cheese frosting that has coconut and toasted pecans stirred in*
 
Italian Fudge Cake- The best of both worlds… our scrumptious Italian cake made with chocolate butter milk cake. A chocolate twist on a traditional favorite*
 
Kahlua & Cream Cake- This cake was created for our mother’s 60th birthday. I combines two of her favorite drinks, coffee & Kahlua. We took our mocha cake soaked in Kahlua, then covered in whipped creme & topped with chocolate ganache*
 
Mississippi Mud Cake- Chocolate cake covered in chocolate frosting with marshmallow creme piled on top & between the layers then generously sprinkled with toasted pecans & drizzled in chocolate ganache
 
Pina Colada Cake- Coconut cake soaked in sweet coconut rum sauce, layered with crushed pineapple, covered in whipped creme and topped with toasted coconut and a cherry. Sure to be an anytime favorite!
 
White Queen Cake - I made this cake for my daughter Alyssa’s eighth grade graduation luncheon. We wanted something both light and decadent. It was a perfect choice. Vanilla cake filled with vanilla mousse, covered in whipped cream then topped with white ganache, simply delicious*
Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Pineapple Upside Down Cake


 

Decadent Cakes

Our newest addition to our web menu… These cakes are sinfully delicious!  These cakes do not have additional decoration.

Available in: Double layer 8″ round $39.95 or 10″ $59.95

Chocolate Pecan Truffle – A chocolate layer cake torted and filled with dark chocolate ganache, then covered in our made from scratch chocolate icing. This cake is encrusted with toasted pecans.  Our version of a truffle in cake form.

Pina Colada Cake

Pina Colada Cake

Chocolate Praline Crunch- Chocolate layer cake torted and filled with caramel, toffee and toasted pecans, then covered in our delicious chocolate icing.  More caramel, toffee and toasted pecans top this gooey, yet crunchy, decadent cake.

Raspberry Royale- Vanilla layer cake torted and filled with alternating layers of vanilla mousse and raspberry preserves.  This cake is covered in whipped cream and topped with our almost famous white chocolate ganache.  A surprisingly delightful cake, sure to please even royalty.

Cheesecakes

Cheesecake – This recipe has been in our family for over 60 years. Grandma Mason (our mother’s mom) baked this cheese cake only on special occasions. A traditional New York style cheese cake that is rich, creamy and delicious. Once you try it no other will do
 
Original - $16.95
Cherry or Chocolate Ganache Topped - $19.95
Strawberry, Chocolate Covered Cherry or Turtle – $21.95
Chocolate Ganache & Whole Strawberries – $29.95
Chocolate Dipped Strawberry Cheesecake- $39.95
 
 
Layer Cheesecakes – Our incredible, creamy cheesecake taken to another level, sandwiched between two layers of moist cake then iced in one of our delicious frostings. – $34.95
 
Black Forrest- Our newest layer cheese cake! Cheese cake layered between chocolate cake, covered in whipped creme, topped with cherries & drizzled with chocolate ganache. The best of two world collide to bring a new twist to two old favorites!
 
Black & White- Cheesecake layered between chocolate cake, covered in chocolate frosting & topped with ganache
 
Cafe Au Lait- Cheesecake layered between capuccino cake, covered in mocha frosting & topped with ganache.
 
Lemon Chiffon- Cheesecake layered between lemon cake covered in whipped creme & topped with lemon custard

Black & White Cheesecake

Black & White Cheesecake

 
Red Devil – Cheesecake layered between rich, red velvet cake & smothered in cream cheese frosting.
 
Tahitian – Cheesecake layered betwen coconut cake, iced in cream cheese frosting & covered in toasted coconut

Cookies

Cookie “Cakes”

Big Cookie- An 8″ cookie in your choice of chocolate chip, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, sugar & snicker doodle decorated with your choice of balloons or flowers. $13.95 Add an edible image or cake kit for $5.00 more
 
Really Big Cookie- A 12″ cookie decorated with balloons or flowers $23.95 Add an edible image or cake kit for $5.oo more

Home Style Cookies

79¢ each 3/$2.25 $7.95 dozen
All our cookies are made from scratch family recipes using high quality ingredients including real chocolate chips, baking cocoa & peanut butter. Our cookies are baked fresh daily
Chocolate Chip • Oatmeal Raisin • Peanut Butter Ono Mikomiko
No Bake • Sugar • Snickerdoodle

Iced Butter Cookies

$1.05 each 3/$3.00 $10.95 dozen
Thick, buttery, hand cut into fun shaped cookies with colorful icing

Bars & Brownies

$1.25 each 3/$3.50 $12.95 dozen
 
Chocolate Chip Pecan Brownies – Kristi’s secret recipe brownies, filled with toasted pecans, real chocolate chips. They are simply delicious
 
Peanut Butter Toffee Bars – A yummy peanut butter bar made even better with a hint of toffee and white chocolate chips and of course peanuts

Signature Cookies

$1.50 each 3/$4.25 $15.00/dozen
 
Double Dip Cookies – Chocolate Chip or Peanut Butter cookie dipped in white & milk chocolate
 
Jammers – Our hand cut butter cookies sandwiched with raspberry jam & sprinkled with powdered sugar
 
Lemony Snippets – A big lemon sugar cookie covered in yummy lemon glaze
 

Decadent Treats

$2.25 each 3/$6.00 $22.50 dozen
 
Death By Chocolate – Our chocolate chip cookies baked into a double chocolate pecan brownie crust then filled with rich chocolate ganache
 
Cookie Monster – Two made from scratch chocolate chip cookies stuffed with butter cream frosting & rolled in rainbow sprinkles
 
Cake Pops - Cake & icing mixed together, rolled into a ball then dipped in chocolate and covered in sprinkes. We put this new treat on a stick for easy handling (ok we put it on a stick because it’s fun) Available in Butter Cake • Funfetti • Chocolate  • Red Velvet • Strawberry • Peppermint

Party Trays

All our party trays are filled with delicious made from scratch cookies & brownies that are sure to be the hit of any party!

Cookie Tray

 
Cookie Tray- Three dozen of our made from scratch home style cookies $24.95
 
Brownie Bites Tray – Six dozen bite size chocolate chip, pecan brownies $24.95
 
Cookie & Brownie Tray – Two dozen home style cookies & two dozen chocolate chip, pecan brownie bites $24.95

Deluxe Cookie Tray

 
Jumbo Cookie Tray – Five dozen home style cookies $42.95
 
Deluxe Cookie Tray – Four dozen home style cookies plus a dozen iced butter cookies $45.95
 
Chocolate Lovers Tray – This tray is a chocolate lovers dream… filled with 18 chocolate chip cookies & 18 no bake cookies, plus two dozen chocolate chip pecan brownie bites & a dozen double dip cookies $49.95
 
Ultimate Party Tray – This tray has it all… three dozen home style cookies (six of each kind), a dozen iced butter cookies & a dozen of our double dipped cookies $52.95

 

Gift Baskets

Add a Teddy Bear to your Basket for just $5.00!

Sampler Basket

Petite Cookie Basket- Six sugar cookies, two brownies & two iced butter cookies plus an chocolate covered pretzel $16.95
 
Sweet Heart Basket - One dozen home style cookies, four pieces of candy, three iced butter cookies & a chocolate dipped pretzel $21.95
 
Sweet Treats – One dozen home style cookies, six chocolate chip pecan brownies & iced butter cookies $26.95
 
Sampler Basket – One dozen home style cookies, six of each: chocolate chip pecan brownies, iced butter cookies & hand made candies plus two chocolate covered pretzels $34.95
 
Deluxe Basket – A dozen home style cookies, six of each: brownies, iced butter cookies & double dip cookies plus three chocolate covered pretzels $42.95
 
Mega-Sampler – One dozen of each: brownies, home style cookies & iced butter cookies, six hand made candies plus three chocolate covered pretzels $49.95Executive Sweet- Two dozen home style cookies, one dozen iced butter cookies, a dozen chocolate chip pecan brownies, six pieces of hand madecandy & six double dip cookies plus three chocolate covered pretzels $68.95
 
Chocolate Lover’s – A dozen of each home style cookie; chocolate chip & no bakes, one dozen double dip cookies, chocolate chip pecan brownies, & handmade candies. Plus six death by chocolates & three chocolate dipped pretzels $84.95
 
Sweet Temptation – Two dozen home style cookies & a dozen of each; chocolate chip pecan brownies, iced butter cookies, double dip cookies & hand made candies plus six chocolate covered pretzels & six death by chocolates $105.95
 
Ultimate Indulgence- This basket is filled with over 100 delicious treats, making it truly the ultimate indulgence! Includes three dozen home style cookies, one dozen of each: iced butter cookies, chocolate chip pecan brownies, hand made candies, & double dip cookies & chocolate covered pretzels & two bags of wonderland trail mix $139.95

Ultimate Indulgance Basket

All our gift baskets can be shipped!

We reserve the right to make substitutions of equal or greater value to our gift baskets.

Candy

Candy Cups – 50¢

Peanut Butter Creams – Smooth white chocolate blended with chunky peanut butter
 
Hay Stacks – A classic. Dark chocolate & toasted coconut
 
Chocolate Crisps – Milk chocolate blended with crisp rice
 
Toffee Bites – Creamy white chocolate & crunchy toffee bits
 
Wonderland Trail Mix – Pretzels, peanuts, toasted cerial, M&M’s covered in white chocolate. Simply delicious! 8oz. $6.95

Pretzels

Chocolate Covered Pretzels

$2.25 each 3/$6.00 $22.50 dozen
 
Caramel Pretzel – A caramel dipped pretzel rod covered in milk chocolate
 
Cash Cow – A caramel dipped pretzel rod, rolled in toasted cashews then covered in white chocolate
 
Peppermint Stick - A dark chocolate dipped pretzel rod rolled in crunchy peppermint then dipped again dark chocolate
 
Toffee Pretzel – A caramel dipped pretzel rod rolled in crunchy toffee bits & covered in white chocolate
 
Trinidad – A caramel dipped pretzel rod rolled in toasted coconut then covered in dark chocolate
 
Turtle Pretzel – A caramel dipped pretzel rod rolled in toasted pecans then covered in milk chocolate

“We have the happiest birthday cakes in town”

Really Big Cookie

Really Big Cookie

Chocolate Covered Cherry Cheese Cake

Chocolate Covered Cherry Cheese Cake

 

Italian Cream Cake

Italian Cream Cake

Chocolate Covered Cherry Cake

Chocolate Covered Cherry Cake

Banana Cream Cake

Banana Cream Cake

mocha icing & topped with chocolate ganache. If you like coffee & chocolate you will love this dessert*

Peanut Butter Flip

Peanut Butter Flip

Pink Coconut Cake

Pink Coconut Cake

Website by The Computer Group